You’re Next (2011) Review (Yeah – the current horror film)

20130902-125604 AM.jpg
You’re Next (2011?? What? Apparently so… Looks like it spent a couple years at film festivals first)

Directed by Adam Wingard

Sharni Vinson
Nicholas Tucci
Wendy Glenn
A. J. Bowen
Joe Swanberg
Barbara Crampton
Rob Moran
Ti West

Running time: 95 minutes

Plot Synopsis:

The Davison family gathers at a remote house in the woods (as you do) to celebrate the 35th wedding anniversary of their parents. While celebrating, the family is attacked by a gang of masked invaders.

20130902-125704 AM.jpg
My Opinion:

It’s been too long since I’ve gone to a movie (like, a month!). After spending the past couple of days catching up on reading all the blogs here, I read loads of extremely positive reviews for You’re Next (plus one blogger who hated it). So, even though I’m not really a modern horror fan and a massive wuss about gore, I said what the hell as it’s only 95 minutes long and went to it.

Now, I’m just back from this and still trying to collect my thoughts but figure I should get this review out there quick otherwise I’ll never get around to it. Normally I like to think about the film for a day or two. I’m not entirely sure yet how I feel about it. I think there are some good things about it but I was disappointed that there wasn’t even more dark humor than there actually was – from the reviews I read I thought there’d be a little more of that. What there was, I enjoyed (especially at the end).

20130902-125736 AM.jpg
I liked that there’s a strong female lead. I get bored with women in horror movies seeming to only be there to flash their tits and then die horribly. I suppose I liked some of the more “inventive” deaths but, not being a fan of gore or slasher flicks (other than the cheesy 70s & 80s ones), it was a bit hard to watch. And I didn’t exactly watch the screen the whole time! So… I suppose I’m not actually the best judge on just HOW gory it got. Certainly sounded rather, um… Juicy at times! Okay – I think it’ll be easier to just break this one down into what I liked and didn’t like so much…

20130902-125817 AM.jpg
What I liked:

– Like I said, a strong female lead who isn’t just there to show us her boobs.

– Some inventive deaths although really too violent for this wuss.

– Barbara Crampton played the mom. And she’s aged really well. The chick from Re-Animator! And Chopping Mall, which I love but shouldn’t. That kind of horror is more my speed… And, um, The Young & The Restless! I used to watch it when I lived in America, okay?! So sue me. :-p

– The animal masks were pretty cool.

– The dark humor but I wished there’d been more .

– The fact that the guy who directed a movie I just happened to watch two nights ago (Ti West – The Innkeepers) is actually in this. (I love IMDB). FYI: I preferred The Innkeepers to this.

– The length. Maybe bad for a film-lover to admit but I think horrors & comedies don’t need to be much more than an hour and a half long.

– The music at the end. It was a bit… I don’t know. Reminded me of The Thing with a little bit of Dawn of the Dead? I know too little about movie music to continue this discussion – just thought it worked well at the end of the film.

– The second half. I thought it started out quite slow and took a fairly long time to get interesting. But it really picked up speed about halfway through.

20130902-125904 AM.jpg
What I Didn’t Like So Much:

– Too violent.

– Not enough of the dark humor – more would have made this one better. I’m not talking Tucker And Dale Vs Evil levels of humor (I loved that one – and it gives me a chance to link to a review of mine, I guess! Review HERE). But there’s so little that it almost felt out of place.

– Felt a little pointless (PART 1). We’ve seen home invasion movies a lot and others have done it better. It felt like a pretty standard home invasion flick but with more gore. It will be and probably has been compared to The Strangers, which I thought was better in terms of suspense & creepiness. Also think I preferred the film Ils (Them). And (I’m going to get in big trouble for this one and have a bunch of you horror fans yelling at me) I liked The Purge better than You’re Next (I won’t go into full detail on that now – my review is HERE if you’re bothered). The Purge at least had a great concept even though it wasn’t as well executed as it could have been. You’re Next has an extremely simple concept we’ve already seen many times but its execution was better than that of The Purge. So I guess it depends on what you prefer from a film…

– Felt a little pointless (PART 2). As far as the violence… I don’t always get as into violent films like these when the people don’t seem THAT horrible but we have to watch them die in awful ways. Other bloggers have said the family is unlikeable so it’s fun watching them die but, aside from a brother who comes across as a prick, they don’t really seem deserving of the excessive violence. But that’s probably just me – I’m not a fan of all the torture porn that’s around these days. You’re Next doesn’t fall into that category but the violence feels a little unnecessary at times. Or… Pointless. Not that every film (and certainly not every horror film) NEEDS to have a point. But… I don’t know what I’m trying to say so I’ll sum this up now.

20130902-125938 AM.jpg

You’re Next is a pretty standard home invasion flick but with more gore, a couple inventive deaths, and a sprinkle of dark humor. Horror fans who love the more violent films of the genre will like this one. Luckily a strong female lead helps make up for some of the film’s weaknesses and the final half of the film is much stronger than what I thought was a pretty slow start. Overall I don’t think it’s a bad film – it’s a decent enough film for its genre but doesn’t feel as fresh & original as I was kind of expecting from the many reviews that I’d read. Maybe I’m just too picky these days?

My Rating: 6/10

20130902-010003 AM.jpg
**I suppose I’ve not even mentioned the other horror film that’s received lots of praise this year too – The Conjuring. Much more my type of horror and I feel it’s more worthy of the praise it received. Review HERE.

31 thoughts on “You’re Next (2011) Review (Yeah – the current horror film)

  1. Good review! I don’t think you are being too picky. A 6 is pretty much a spot on rating from what I have read. I still would like to see it. Good job!

  2. You know how I felt, so no need to rehash my thoughts. Given that you’re not fond of gore, I’m surprised you’d still give this a 6. To me the gore was the only point so I would’ve expected a lower rating.

    By the way, I completely agree with you about horror movies and comedies (animated films too). 90 min is the sweet spot. Anything longer is pushing it.

    • Yeah, you were the one I meant when I said “one blogger who didn’t like it”. 😉

      I’m not a fan of horror these days so much but have to admit that I liked 70s & 80s “slashers” so I don’t see a film like this as much different, just that special effects are (unfortunately!) much better these days so the results are much more gory than in the old days. I can’t stomach things like Saw, Hostel – all that torture porn. I admit that this one kind of walks that thin line but I’d say it still doesn’t fall into that category. The violence felt a bit over the top but not any more so than what you see in a Tarantino film and those AREN’T considered horror. As You’re Next is a horror film, I was expecting the violence and actually get more disturbed by violence in mainstream films when you aren’t necessarily expecting it. I’m probably not making my point here. Actually, I’m not sure what my point IS. Lol. For me, You’re Next was too violent. I’m not great with violence in any film of any genre but know what I’m getting into when watching a modern horror film so am more “lenient” about the violence.

      I suppose I gave it a 6 as, for its genre, I thought it was decent. So compared to other modern horror films it’s okay. I gave The Conjuring a higher rating as I liked that one much more (and no gore!). 🙂

  3. I can understand your arguement but I think the female lead is what separates it from other home invasion films. She was great she is a rare character that you will find in horror films. Nice review.

  4. Nice review! Haven’t seen the film yet, but I feel like I’m probably gonna feel the same way. Sounds like we’re on the same page with abundant gore–gory isn’t scary, just gross and I’m sick of not being able to watch half a horror film because of it!

    • Yep – we seem to feel exactly the same way. I miss my old school slashers where I could actually watch the screen the entire time as the “gory” special effects were so fake & cheesy! Lol. I struggle with Tarantino films as well. I’m actually a massive wuss! Just really like horror as a genre and hate that, in this day & age, they’re rarely GOOD anymore and I’ve actually almost completely stopped watching them. :-/ The Conjuring was a pleasant surprise for a modern ghost story. And no gore!!! 🙂

      • Again, totally on the same page! Haha. Although I don’t think disliking gore makes anyone a wuss. Cheesy old school gore is one thing, but when it looks real…ugh. Seems weird to enjoy that. And I loved The Conjuring! One of my top summer movies 🙂

      • Yep – sounds like we like the same sort of “horror”. 🙂 I’ll never like torture porn – I just don’t get the appeal! :-/ The Conjuring was a nice return to the old fashioned haunted house stories. Much more me! I’m more into supernatural than horror most of the time, I suppose.

  5. Is that the Wyatt Family?!? (Google it.) This looks scary as hell, what with that garage so far away from the kitchen. How am I ever gonna get me a sammich after a long night of work?

    • Lol! Yes, I had to Google that. I thought some poor Wyatt family had been murdered but see it’s one of your wrestling things. 😉

      Dude. Don’t watch it. You’ll never eat a sandwich again. Or pie.

  6. Good review, I guess I liked it a bit more than you did, but I totally see where you think it’s not entirely original and I agree that it is pretty bad in the violence department at times. I think I went in preparing for worse, so I was okay in that area. I thought it was an interesting commentary on what people might do for money, so there was a little bit of distinction there for this movie, other than for the sake of seeing people getting hacked up in different ways. Still, horror’s not really my thing. . . .

  7. Pingback: From Beyond (1986) Review for Halloween Horror Fest | Cinema Parrot Disco

  8. Pingback: The Purge: Anarchy (2014) Review | Cinema Parrot Disco

  9. Pingback: The Guest (2014) Review | Cinema Parrot Disco

  10. Pingback: Ready Or Not (2019) Review | Cinema Parrot Disco

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s