Today’s IMDB Top 250 Guest Review comes from John of 501 Must See Movies Project . He also reviewed Amadeus HERE. Thanks for the reviews, John! 🙂 Now let’s hear his thoughts on Platoon, IMDB rank 144 out of 250…
There are still some movies up for grabs if anyone wants to do a guest IMDB Top 250 review. You can find the list of remaining films HERE. See the full list & links to all the reviews that have already been done HERE. I’ve stopped receiving so many guest reviews now so if you send yours soon, it should post soon. I only have enough for the next month.
The first casualty of war is innocence.
Charlie Taylor (Charlie Sheen) is a green, fresh to arrive recruit in Vietnam. Platoon follows Taylor and his company as they cope with the hardships of war, and the film brings back the reality of what went on over there to the big screen for the first time since Apocalypse Now (1979).
The unit breaks into two contrasting camps: one with Sgt. Barnes (Tom Berenger), who believes in total war and winning at any cost, and Sgt. Elias (Willem Dafoe), who is battle-tested but gracious in contrast to Barnes. Each side as plenty of support, and they battle, as Taylor puts it, “for possession of my soul.”
Platoon features a whole slew of familiar faces (Charlie Sheen, Tom Berenger, Willem Dafoe, Keith David, Johnny Depp, Forest Whitaker, John C. McGinley, Tony Todd, Mark Moses), many of which were at the beginning of their careers.
A couple of things added to the authenticity of this film. Oliver Stone’s experience in Vietnam, woven throughout the characters Taylor encounters, and the preparation the actors went through in making this film. They trained for two weeks before filming began, building camaraderie as a unit, digging foxholes, encountering “night attacks” to get used to the special effects that would be used. The familiarity these actors had with their weapons made the actions and emotion seem genuine.
The acting in this film is top-notch. The characters evoke strong emotions in the audience: you either really like or really hate what a person says or does. I found myself completely disgusted with some of the men in the Barnes camp as they abused and mistreated both Vietnamese peasants and their fellow soldiers. An interesting commentary on this came from Taylor as he was airlifted out at the end of the film. He describes that the Vietnamese weren’t the enemy, instead we were our own enemy. There is a lot of killing, granted, but more of it being American killing American than one would expect.
I believe I’ve said it before, but Willem Dafoe is probably one of my favorite actors. This film is one of the reasons for that opinion. He is a strong, committed character whose performance I felt stood above all the others. I also found it interesting that he never wear a helmet. Ever. Tom Berenger, though I don’t agree with his characters outlook and way of carrying himself, brings that type of soldier to life and it fully committed to his character.
Charlie Sheen does very well in this movie as well. The contrast and how quickly his idealized or unaware outlook at the beginning of the film is quickly shredded and almost gone by the end of the film. He quickly loses the label of ‘new meat’ and becomes one of the guys. His judgement and discernment remain, though, which is refreshing and relieving.
It’s interesting seeing John C. McGinley in a role like this after watching him at Dr. Cox on Scrubs, but hey that might just be me.
Platoon is considered one of the best films of the 1980s, it won the Best Picture Oscar in 1987. It’s authenticity and superb acting both contribute largely to its success. It’s one I enjoyed, and I’d definitely recommend seeing.
My Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars.
The problem with this movie for me is Charlie Sheen, not that there was anything wrong with his work at the time. It is just that sometimes where an actors career goes after being an A-lister can often influence your opinion about them so strongly that you can not escape thinking about them in a negative way even when looking at their great earlier work. That is how I feel about him, and for me personally it takes away from what he did in Platoon to the point where I would not actually want to watch it again.
He’s certainly off his rocker now… ; )
Thanks for the review, John! I did like this one. For a war movie. Dafoe was great. : )
Honestly, I’m not a huge fan of this movie BUT I saw it after I started hating Oliver Stone so I may be biased…..
Nice write up in any case!
What movie made you hate Oliver Stone, then? Can’t say I’m a big fan…
You’ll probably REALLY hate me for this but…..
…. Natural Born Killers (and then Alexander)…
Never saw them!
Those two movies……….. —> SUCKED
I’m not really interested in seeing either of them : )
Haha. No. Maybe NBK.
It’s my list for you…………………
Don’t be mean!!!
As long as I don’t have to poop at work I am generally in a good mood 🙂
There are some really affecting messages about the futility of war and how quickly we can separate ourselves from our humanity.
Yeah – what Abbi said! ; )
I liked Charlie Sheen back in the day, and for me Oliver Stone films are a crapshoot, but I enjoyed this one. Though The story revolves around Sheen’s character, the rest of the cast balances him out.
This is certainly Oliver Stone’s best. Although I do have a soft spot for The Doors. : )
Pingback: A Beautiful Mind (2001) IMDB Top 250 Guest Review | Cinema Parrot Disco