The Giver by Lois Lowry (Book Review)

IMG_6848.JPG

The Giver by Lois Lowry

What It’s About:

Jonas is an 11-year-old boy in a future where there is no war, suffering or pain. He and his family unit follow strict rules within their community including things such as the precision of language and the sharing of feelings and dreams. Everyone is assigned a role in life at the Ceremony of Twelve and no one is more surprised than Jonas when, at his ceremony, he’s selected as the next Receiver of Memory. During his training, he starts to discover that his community may not be as perfect as it seems.

My Thoughts:

I’ll be honest and admit that I’d never even HEARD of this book before seeing that there would be a movie coming out but it appears that it was quite a famous (and somewhat controversial) one. Published in 1993, I was just too old for it. After spending my pre-teens reading Sweet Valley High then moving onto Christopher Pike, I discovered Stephen King around 12 or 13 and read nothing but him for years. The Giver is a good one, though – I wish there’d been more “dystopian future” YA books when I was young so I could have grown up with those instead of just things like Sweet Valley High (not that I’m dissing Sweet Valley High. It ruled! I even wrote to Francine Pascal & got a SVH audio book in return). 😉 I know the dystopian thing is WAY overdone when it comes to YA fiction these days but, believe me, there wasn’t much of it for us 80’s kids.

It’s a shame that The Giver will be seen as “just another dystopian YA book” now. I’ve only read some of the more current ones, such as The Hunger Games, but The Giver strikes me as being much more simple and aimed at a younger age than the current YA type of books (I’d say maybe ages 9 or 10 to early teens?). I don’t mean “simple” in a bad way, though. I think some of the current stuff can be a bit overblown and, as much as I loved the first two Hunger Games books, the final one was a bit over the top and I found it very disappointing. If I had a pre-teen kid, I’d start them off with The Giver as their introduction to these types of books and it’s one I’d be very happy to have them read as I think it teaches some basic yet important lessons in a way that’s easy for them to understand. It doesn’t overdo things – it actually leaves plenty of things up to the reader to decide and I’m sure makes for some very good discussion (I know it’s apparently read in a lot of schools). Basically, and I’ve said this before, The Giver is Brave New World plus a bit of Fahrenheit 451 for pre-teens and I don’t see that as a bad thing at all. I love things like Brave New World and 1984 and I think The Giver is a great introduction to books like those. I’d highly recommend it to kids of today (or to their parents to encourage their kids to read it) as I think it’s more suitable for them than a lot of current YA fiction seems to be. I can understand why it won the Newbery Medal and is seen as a bit of a modern classic.

Summary:

I realize I haven’t discussed the actual story or characters in this book at all. Jonas is by far the most developed character but, being a fairly short children’s book, we don’t get much character development with anyone. The story is what’s more important here and I found it a solid story that effectively gets its point across and also manages a “good ending” that stays with you (in my opinion – but I won’t go into that at all as I always try to avoid any spoilers). Some may be critical of it being over simplistic but I find that a bit ridiculous as it’s aimed at a pre-teen audience. I also JUST watched the movie a few hours ago, which I’ll try to review over the next few days. I know I’ve not gone into much detail but movie reviews are really more my thing – I’m sure I’ll be discussing things much more in the movie review. All I’ll say about it for now is: READ THE BOOK INSTEAD!!! I highly recommend this book to pre-teens, their parents, and people like me who still enjoy a decent story no matter what age it may be aimed at.

My Rating: 4/5

Advertisements

23 thoughts on “The Giver by Lois Lowry (Book Review)

  1. It’s a standard text for 8th graders. It feels abstract to a lot of teens, but when taught well, the principles behind it are why it’s a classic and a worthy read. A world without feelings–what a horrible thought! Good or bad, it’s what makes us human. I hear the film is different in some ways, but Lois gave her two thumbs up, so enjoy!

  2. I actually never read this one and in 93 I was 13 and I remember it was always being promoted at school, but I never had to read it. And hello Sweet Valley High ruled!! I was totally into that I even had the board game. It was pretty awesome! Right along with Babysitters Club books. I can’t believe they sent you an audio book in return, I mean back in the day that was pretty cool, so futuristic. hahaha Interested in hearing what you have to say about the movie. 🙂

  3. Nice review, lady! I’ve never read this one, but I need to. I heard the movie was a disappointment, which is a shame. It’s also a shame that the good dystopian stuff is getting buried by this surge of new–and not all good–stuff. Book/movie fads are fun for a while…until they’re annoying. Lol.

  4. We studied this in English class when I was 13 and I loved it so much! It was such an interesting concept back then that unfortunately sounds like “just another dystopian YA novel” now. Big shame! Looking forward to seeing the film though!

  5. I had to read it in college and liked it. It was fairly new back then. The trailer for the film looks like they took it and tried twisting it into a teen angst story which isn’t what the book was.

    • Yep – they did turn it a bit into “teen angst” but what was worse is that they really upped the romance that really wasn’t in the book AT ALL. What a shame. :-/ They really do mess up movie adaptations sometimes…

  6. Well, you know I tossed this on my list. Finishing up a few other books and what not at the moment, but this one looks like it is good. I like that you gave no spoilers, I was able to read the entire body of your text.

    I can totally understand your reading habits, though I read SVH simply because it was what my school library had. I read a lot of Nancy Drew and the Hardy Boys (not this new age crap they are doing), but when I was like eleven or something they gave me access to the adult section, and my life was changed forevermore! ❤

    • Lol – I stayed pretty young in my tastes with SVH, Judy Blume, Christopher Pike & RL Stine but there was no going back once I finally discovered Stephen King. 😉 (it was actually a collection of short stories first – Night Shift. LOVE his short stories) 🙂

      • Ah man, I LOVED RL Stine books when I was a kid. I would read any and every single one I could get my hands on. Pike, too. I read Night Shift this year. I can’t remember my first King novel, but I remember his first short story collection I read was Nightmares and Dreamscapes. I love all his work.

  7. Pingback: My Top (Seven) Books Read In 2014 (and mini-reviews!) | Cinema Parrot Disco

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s