The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance (1962) IMDB Top 250 Review


An IMDB review by me! Finally! I’ve been slacking…

The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance (1962)

IMDB Rank: 208 out of 250 (as of 01/01/2013)

Directed by John Ford

John Wayne
James Stewart
Vera Miles
Lee Marvin
Edmond O’Brien
Woody Strode
Andy Devine
John Carradine
Lee Van Cleef

Running time: 123 minutes

Plot Synopsis: (via IMDB)
A senator, who became famous for killing a notorious outlaw, returns for the funeral of an old friend and tells the truth about his deed.


My Opinion:

It’s me! Reviewing a Top 250 film on my own blog! I’ve really neglected this Top 250 project while I’ve let all of you review them for me instead. I’ve reviewed all of the Studio Ghibli films in the Top 250 but, besides those, it looks like my last review was of Unforgiven last September. And here I am now with another damn Western (which I watched last September. I’m so behind!). I have to say that of the two things I was dreading in the Top 250, Westerns & war movies, I’m far preferring the war movies so far. (Once Upon A Time In The West was pretty awesome, though).


So… John Wayne! This is the first & only John Wayne movie I’ve watched in my life. His movies were of such a different era that I really can’t relate to in any sort of way & I’ve never had any interest in exploring any of his films. I remember flipping through channels once as a teen & there was some John Wayne movie on where he was spanking a woman. Spanking?! Not in some weird, kinky, S&M way but I got the impression that she was maybe his wife & had disobeyed him or something so that was her punishment. (Okay – I can’t believe I just Googled “John Wayne Spanking” but I did & the movie was a year after this one & called McLintock!). Anyway, that sort of sexism just wouldn’t fly today so I can see why John Wayne films aren’t exactly popular amongst a new generation whereas the Sergio Leone Spaghetti Westerns still are. They’re beautiful, sweeping epics (I assume – I’m basing this only on Once Upon A Time In The West) while John Wayne’s “spanking movie” feels like it’s from 50 years before West instead of just five. Having said that, though, The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance is pretty good & nothing like the very limited knowledge I have of other John Wayne films which had a very old look & feel. I think the fact that it was in black & white helped to keep it feeling less “dated” in an odd sort of way plus I think “serious drama” works much better in the Western genre than “silly spank comedy”. Also, what helped a lot for me was the fact that James Stewart was in this. I love Jimmy! That’s what convinced me to watch this one instead of putting it off (unfortunately, it’s no longer in the Top 250 like it was when I started this project).


IMG_0372This is Liberty Valance. SPOILER: he gets shot…

I think this movie has a really good story & I liked the way it’s revealed in flashback as a small group of old friends gather for a funeral. James Stewart plays an educated lawyer & politician while John Wayne plays the rugged silent hero type but, hey – these are the exact kind of roles these two are known for & they’re perfect in this film. I’ll admit I got a little bored in the middle when the political stuff was going on (James Stewart running for some political something or other) but the scenes between Stewart & Wayne as well as the scenes involving the big baddie terrorizing the small community (Liberty Valance, played just right by Lee Marvin) were great. I also enjoyed the little bit of a love triangle between Stewart, Wayne & Vera Miles. So there are a lot of big stars in this one (including Lee Van Cleef although I can’t say I really remember him in it now – I don’t think it was a huge role). But my favorite actor in this (after Stewart) would be Woody Strode. He has a pretty big role as Wayne’s ranch hand & close friend. He was also in the incredible opening scene of Once Upon A Time In The West and has such a great look. I’d totally want to cast him in a movie if I ever made one (but he’s kind of not alive anymore). I looked him up & see that his last role was in that Sharon Stone/Leonardo DiCaprio Western The Quick And The Dead at the age of 80. Makes me want to watch that silly looking movie now – would be fun to see a young Leo again as well. Here’s Strode in this & West:




I know I don’t have much experience with Westerns but I can say that, as someone who isn’t a fan of the genre, I thought The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance was pretty good. I really enjoyed the story plus the characters were very well-developed and you cared what was going to happen to them & to their close friendships. You love the goodies & hate the baddies in this one, which is really the point of all Westerns, isn’t it? It’s a shame this isn’t in the Top 250 anymore as young people keep voting in current shit like Interstellar, meaning all the older films are being overlooked and will now probably be totally ignored. This one is worth a watch if you like a decent good guy vs bad guy movie filled with revenge, love, loyalty and loss.

My Rating: 7/10



22 thoughts on “The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance (1962) IMDB Top 250 Review

  1. I LOVE this movie. It gets a 10 from me, though I am a huge John Wayne and Jimmy Stewart fan. I am also a huge western fan and John Wayne was one of the men who helped make them famous over the years. You should really give a few more a try at some point, many of them are very different thematically and in tone. Some can be absolutely hilarious and others quite poignant. Spaghetti westerns are good, but there is nothing better than relaxing and letting the Duke take you out of it for a couple of hours. Great review btw!

    • Thanks for the comment! I thought I’d never get one on this… I’m thinking my followers aren’t John Wayne fans! Lol. šŸ™‚ Glad to hear from someone who’s a fan of this – I’ve known some people who really loved this one but haven’t heard it mentioned in years. I don’t know… I still can’t see me loving John Wayne… šŸ˜‰ I’m not sure – I think there may be another movie of his in the Top 250, in which case I’ll have to watch that at some point. This one surprised me, though – was better than I was expecting. What I do like about John Wayne is that he makes me think of a couple of my great-uncles – farmers who liked watching Wayne’s movies. šŸ™‚

      • Oh yeah – I’ve heard of that one! Hmm. No, doesn’t look like it is. Think I was thinking of High Noon, which isn’t John Wayne. Confusing my Westerns! I may watch The Searchers someday anyway. šŸ™‚

  2. I haven’t seen this, and it sounds good and all, but I mainly came here to say:


    …Okay I’m done. šŸ˜‰

  3. I think it’s kind of unfortunate that genre fans aren’t able to assess movies well. My first taste of this was with friends in college who were anime fans … after unsuccessfully trying to understand the appeal of flying Japanese girls with kitty ears, I happened to watch Grave of the Fireflies and was blown away. Westerns are the same way. I recently watched The Searchers and found I couldn’t get on board with the racism against Indians [sic] that is so necessary to the plot (not much more than that in the blog ). Nonetheless, I think it is an excellent example of a Western. What I like is characters who have the illusion of history beyond the bounds of the film, and I like for there to be a sense of fairness. As someone who is not a fan of the genre per se, I would recommend Bad Day at Black Rock, about a man who returns to a small town to visit a friend only to find he died under mysterious circumstances. ( for some more details and an amusing anecdote about how I found it.)

    • Well, yeah – I’m one of those who definitely prefers Studio Ghibli to Westerns. I’ve reviewed most of those (as well as Grave of the Fireflies) so hopefully I did a slightly better job assessing those. šŸ˜‰ Hmm… I doubt that The Searchers is my type of thing. I now have Iron Maiden’s Run To The Hills in my head after reading your review, though, so that’s pretty awesome! Lol. What you’ve written about Bad Day At Black Rock sounds quite interesting… That might be one I’d be more likely to watch. Thanks for the recommendation! šŸ™‚

  4. You might want to really educate yourself on westerns before actually creating a blog. You clearly know nothing about them. So disappointed! And seriously, John Wayne was an amazing actor. He has made amazing movies! James Stewart, Charles Bronson, Henry Ford, Maureen O’Hara, Lorne Greene, I can go on forever. Westerns had amazing actors. Again, educate yourself before you start spouting off what’s good and not. I have watched every western known and they all bring different plots, themes, stories, etc to the table. You should seriously take this blog down, you have no background in it!!!!!!!

  5. Pingback: My Top Ten Hats In Movies | Cinema Parrot Disco

  6. Pingback: The Good, The Bad And The Ugly (1966) IMDB Top 250 Review | Cinema Parrot Disco

  7. Pingback: A Separation (2011) IMDB Top 250 Review & The Films I’ve Watched So Far (Ranked!) | Cinema Parrot Disco

  8. Pingback: Paths Of Glory & On The Waterfront IMDB Top 250 Reviews | Cinema Parrot Disco

  9. Pingback: IMDB Top 250 Challenge Update: Only 50 Left To Go | Cinema Parrot Disco

  10. Pingback: My IMDb Top 250 Challenge Rankings So Far | Cinema Parrot Disco

  11. Pingback: Watched, Read, Reviewed: February 2022 | Cinema Parrot Disco

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s