**SPOILER-FREE (and meaningless rambling) REVIEW**
Directed & Written by M. Night Shyamalan
Starring: James McAvoy, Anya Taylor-Joy, Betty Buckley, Haley Lu Richardson, Jessica Sula, Brad William Henke, Sebastian Arcelus, Neal Huff
Plot Synopsis: (via IMDB)
After three girls are kidnapped by a man with 24 distinct personalities they must find some of the different personalities that can help them while running away and staying alive from the others.
This is one of those movies where I walked out of the cinema not entirely sure how I felt about it. At first, I mainly thought it was just okay. But the more I thought about it, the more I disliked it. Now, writing this a day after seeing it, I think my main feeling for Split is disappointment. I didn’t hate it. I certainly didn’t love it. A return to form for M. Night Shyamalan? Possibly. But it’s mainly a return to his ability to make movies I’m really interested in seeing as I love the setups and I do enjoy them when I’m in the middle of watching them but, thinking about them later on, I realize they’re not actually very good films (other than The Sixth Sense, to which I still remain faithful).
I think I feel quite similar about Split as I do The Visit (which I reviewed HERE), although they’re very different. I don’t think either is a horrible film and they’re indeed much better than some of M. Night’s huge stinkers in recent years but both are still extremely flawed, especially in their final acts. Split is probably the “better” film in that it’s played straight with some acting that’s of a higher standard than you expect in the horror genre while The Visit is so over-the-top silly that I’m still convinced it’s a horror comedy despite not being labelled as such. But I think Split has made me like The Visit a fraction more in that the latter was a more enjoyable film to sit through despite its silliness. Let’s face it – M. Night’s ideas are silly. Perhaps he should do them in a more comedic fashion as he did in The Visit?? Split takes itself too seriously. The characters are unlikable whereas those in The Visit are so goofily f*%ked-up that you can’t help but kind of like them. Does that make sense?? I’m rambling. Here are all the Shyamalan films I’ve seen ranked from worst to best according to how much I liked them (including one he only wrote):
Lady In The Water
The Sixth Sense
Shut up and talk about the movie, right? You know how hard it is to discuss this dude’s films in a spoiler-free fashion! One thing I’ll say for his movies is this: The majority of them have pretty big name stars and some quality acting despite the horror genre and the often outrageous storylines. I think this has helped to give Shyamalan’s films a bit more credibility than is actually deserved?
As I said, I stand by my opinion that The Sixth Sense is a good piece of filmmaking although people are sometimes negative about it now since the ending is so well known. But everyone involved acted their asses off for that “horror” film (don’t forget that Collette & Osment were up for Acting Oscars as well as Shyamalan for Director & Screenplay and the whole thing for Best Picture!). I don’t think Split’s acting is Oscar calibre but it’s still very good for its kind of film. McAvoy is of course the standout having to play various personalities but I also thought his psychiatrist, Betty Buckley, was very good as was young Anya Taylor-Joy (this is her first film I’ve seen). Oh! And I loved finding out that Betty Buckley was the nice gym teacher in the original Carrie – I didn’t know that until I looked her up just now:
So, bravo to the actors who once again help to elevate an M. Night Shyamalan film. Without them, I think this would be very much in danger of being a bargain bin straight-to-video horror (okay – it’s not straight to “video” anymore, I suppose. Showing my age!). Thanks to the success of The Sixth Sense, I think Shyamalan has been able to continue making films that are just good enough to keep him in the game. I want to like his movies more. I like his ideas but rarely like his execution. I want one of his movies to fully reach its potential (funny, as I do believe this is a line quite often uttered by McAvoy’s character). I also want to stick to my 2017 blog resolution of not writing long, rambling reviews! Let’s wrap this up.
Split isn’t horrible and has some very good performances but is as ultimately disappointing overall as I’ve now come to expect from M. Night Shyamalan’s films. I can see why it has a fairly high IMDB user rating so far as this will either be due to a) loyal fans who’ve watched all his films as he has a surprise in store for them OR b) full-on “horror” fans as this is the most straightforward horror film that Shyamalan has made. It’s more straightforward horror than I like, personally, so perhaps that’s partly why I was disappointed. I prefer bizarre & supernatural, which is why I’ve put up with a lot of the silly shit he’s come up with. So, in some ways, I do agree that this film is a better film than a lot of his work but I personally didn’t like it that much.
Also, two things quite bothered me. The main thing was that I didn’t like some of the treatment of the kidnapped teenage girls. Shyamalan mostly makes “PG-13 horror”. That’s its rating in the U.S. but I wouldn’t let a 13-year-old watch this (it’s rated 15 in the UK). Obviously I want to avoid spoilers but there are sexual themes that I don’t think are necessarily handled that well considering the film’s low rating & young-looking actresses. There’s also an implication that two of the girls “deserve” what terrible fate may await them because, I dunno… They’re popular? They don’t come across as really mean girls or anything.
The other thing is more minor but it just annoyed me. There’s an extra bit tacked onto the VERY end of the movie, as the credits have started to roll with the final scene still going, and it feels extremely out of place. This bit should’ve been a mid or end credits scene. This extra bit is for loyal fans and some of you will love it. Half those in my cinema walked out the second the credits started rolling despite the scene clearly still continuing (why the hell do people do that?!) so those type of people clearly don’t care about this small extra bit anyway. Hey, Mr. Shyamalan! Stick something like that halfway through the credits next time to reward those who stick around! (FYI – I rolled my eyes a bit at this tacked-on scene but also admit I kind of like Shyamalan’s obvious future plan…. Why do I never give up on his films?!)
My Rating: 6/10
I’ll probably wait for the DVD for this one. I do want to see McAvoy because I love him but my expectations are low. Great review!
Thanks! : ) I must say that this is indeed a “wait for DVD” film. Unfortunately. But McAvoy is good.
I’m curious what makes you keep seeing his films. But I’m glad you do as I enjoy your reviews.
Ha! I’m curious too!!! Lol. It’s because I like his ideas. And, one of these times, he MIGHT actually make a good movie from one of them. ; )
Mutester — your honesty always slays me! SLAYS ME!!! (In a good way!) I think you have a really great point about what’s going on with M. Night Shamalamading-dong’s films. (Apologies if that sounded kind of racist, which it did but hey I was going for humor, so. . .)
He always promises SO much and quite often falls short of actually delivering that. His potential is so high and what we have gotten from almost every one of his films is like, I don’t know how to put it other than “an approximation” of what could have been. Does that make any sense at all? Any who — I’m looking forward to Split. It looks like some fun. And it hasn’t gotten completely trounced by critics and bloggers so that’s enough to put me in a chair. Nice review
Haha! I’m glad I slay you (in a good way!). 😀 I think you’re okay – I’ve heard lots of people call him that. ; ) I’m not actually sure how to say his name but glad my phone always remembers how to spell it. Looks like we totally agree on his work. I keep watching as I do really like his ideas. Dammit – I just want one of his movies to be really good sometime. I might happen! So I keep watching. Hope you like this one – it seems to be getting decent praise. : )
Just got my review up for it yesterday. It was . . . . . . well, goddamn it.
Lol. Just read it. That damn ending…. 😉
Effing bollocks Mutey!
So tacky! #CheesyTackyShyamalan
I must be the only person who didn’t enjoy “Sixth Sense”. I liked the twist and the performances but I found the film dull overall. And after turning “Unbreakable” after 20 minutes I have to say that I’ve avoided M. Night Shamalmamamamama films ever since….
I do think The Sixth Sense was a bit slow. But it was still so much better than all he’s done since. Lol – want a tiny spoiler? If you didn’t like Unbreakable, you probably won’t like this. Then again, you only saw 20 minutes of that so wouldn’t know the connection… ; )
Yeah, I don’t think this one will be troubling my “To watch” list any time soon… 😉
I’m actually looking forward to this one. Good review as always!
Thank you! I hope you enjoy it. It certainly has its good points… I just always end up disappointed with Shyamalan’s films. But it’s better than some! : )
I’ve heard good stuff about this on the whole, so I’m still looking forward to it… though maybe not enough to go to the cinema (that’s just cos I’m lazy though). I’ve had the end credits scene spoiled though, which is a shame but also exciting (for me, anyway, because it’s about damn time).
Also, I must re-watch Lady in the Water. I remember quite liking it, but it seems that everybody else really, really hates it.
This is a definite “wait for Netflix” in my opinion. Although, as you know the end scene and you’re excited, you’ll probably like this one okay & the obvious intention for a “trilogy” of sorts. I’ll be honest – I put Lady In The Water last as I barely remember it so figure it can’t have been that good! 😉
Unless I have a change of heart about the cinema, I imagine I’ll rent it. I like his stuff well enough to take that punt. Then I’ll hope he actually makes the third one and buy the inevitable trilogy box set!
Thank you! : )
Pingback: The LEGO Batman Movie (2017) Review | Cinema Parrot Disco
Pingback: October Horror Month 2017 | Cinema Parrot Disco
Reblogged this on Cinema Parrot Disco and commented:
For October Horror Month, here’s a reblog of my January review of Split. I’m still not sure how I feel about this film…
Pingback: October Horror Month Roundup & My Top Ten | Cinema Parrot Disco
Pingback: My Top Ten Movies Of 2017 | Cinema Parrot Disco
Pingback: Glass (2019) Review | Cinema Parrot Disco
Pingback: Old (2021) Review | Cinema Parrot Disco