Neverwhere by Neil Gaiman (Book Review)

Neverwhere by Neil Gaiman

What It’s About: (via Amazon)
Richard Mayhew is a plain man with a good heart — and an ordinary life that is changed forever on a day he stops to help a girl he finds bleeding on a London sidewalk. From that moment forward he is propelled into a world he never dreamed existed — a dark subculture flourishing in abandoned subway stations and sewer tunnels below the city — a world far stranger and more dangerous than the only one he has ever known…

My Thoughts:

This book was the winner when I asked all of you in this poll HERE which book I should read next. I’ll try to read them all in order according to how many votes they have. I’m now also almost done reading the one in second place (Terry Pratchett’s The Colour Of Magic).

Neverwhere is my first Neil Gaiman book. I really do like fantasy novels (and sci-fi) but never really explore those genres as I mostly stick to Stephen King. Easy option that rarely lets me down! I liked Neverwhere. I didn’t love it and I probably won’t rush out & read another Gaiman book based on this one but I’d still read more of his work at some point. I was completely unaware that it was a BBC mini-series first but that they had to leave things out of the show & change things so Gaiman released the original story exactly how he wanted it. I want to see the show now! Although I don’t know anyone in it other than Peter Capaldi…

Actually, I’ve changed my mind – after looking up images from the show, it looks a little dodgy. But back to the book!

The thing the book does best is make some memorable characters. The main character, Richard Mayhew, is so stereotypically British. He reminded me of when Hugh Grant would so often play a charmingly awkward pushover in annoying rom-coms (back in those days when he was dating Liz Hurley & just before he was caught with a hooker). Well, I hated those Hugh Grant characters… Mayhew is more likeable than that. I liked the story of the girl he helps, a character named Door from a bizarre sort of alternate reality in the sewers & subways of London. She has a unique power that I’d have liked to read even more about. There could easily be a prequel to this involving the history of her family & their special gift.

There are many odd characters throughout the story (not to mention the rats, who are an important part of this other reality). There are the Rat-Speakers who can talk to the rats, a pretty kick-ass female bodyguard who would probably be my favorite character in a movie of this if played by the right person, two very dangerous assassins, the Marquis de Carabas, and plenty more I won’t mention to keep some surprises in case any of you want to read this. I did like the clever use of London subway & borough names in developing various characters’ roles in the story.

The most interesting character by far, though, was the Marquis de Carabas. He helps Mayhew & Door on their journey (or does he??). He’s mysterious & suave and you’re not sure if he can be trusted or not. He’d also be awesome in a movie! They really should make this into a movie with a decent budget (the images from the BBC show really do look pretty dodgy). I bought a short story along with this book called How The Marquis Got His Coat Back, which tells an additional story within the time period of this book, and I enjoyed that just as much as the full novel. Gaiman could easily do a spin-off series of Marquis de Carabas stories.

Overall, though, I didn’t quite buy into this story & its world in the way I was hoping that I would. The characters were fun & Gaiman has a great imagination but I didn’t find myself wanting to pick this one up & continue reading it all that often. It really is a world that could be further explored in more books & short stories as there’s a load of potential there. Even the most minor characters’ life stories would make for their own entertaining spin-offs. I can’t really put my finger on why this one didn’t quite work for me as I think all the right elements seem to be there for this to be a book I really love. I can say that I’m thoroughly enjoying Terry Pratchett’s The Colour Of Magic, though, and know I’ll be reading another Pratchett before another Gaiman. Oh well. I’ll read another novel by Neil Gaiman at some point and will happily take recommendations of other books he’s written. I suppose I should read the book he did with Pratchett! 🙂

My Rating: 3.5/5

22 thoughts on “Neverwhere by Neil Gaiman (Book Review)

    • Yep – I said to my hubby that this is soooo “British”. So London. But I don’t mean that in a bad way. I mean, we both married one! ; ) I’ll read something else of his eventually before I make up my mind, I suppose. But I’m not in a huge rush. : )

    • Lol. I’m that way with movies! I have so many on my Watchlist, they’ll take me until 2033 as well. 😉 This was fine – worth a read someday but I’d say you don’t have to rush. : )

  1. I’ve only read Gaiman’s short stories in various anthologies and like them, but wouldn’t say they were my favorites in the collections. So, I am also on the fence about his work. I’m leaning towards feeling it will always be solid material and maybe that’s why he’s popular.

    • Yeah, that’s exactly it… It’s a “solid” book. I mean, I’ve only read this one but that’s how I’d describe it. Which doesn’t sound like a recommendation…. Lol. It IS a fun book but just didn’t fully work for me. I’ll see if I feel differently about his other work. : )

  2. This is something I started reading but had a terrible copy so had to stop. Definitely want to get to it though. I have only ever really read American Gods by Gaiman, and that was a really good book. I thoroughly enjoyed it.

    … so, is Hill next???

    • This is worth trying again. Everyone has recommended American Gods. Well…. I got The Girl on the Train as a gift so I’m reading that quickly. Hill next! : )

  3. Pingback: My Blog’s May 2016 Recap | Cinema Parrot Disco

  4. Pingback: The Colour Of Magic by Terry Pratchett (Book Review) | Cinema Parrot Disco

  5. I loved the miniseries when it first went out, but I’ve never got round to reading the book (I’m terrible at getting round to reading anything). I watched the series again a couple of years ago and think it holds up, though you do have to look past the fact it seems to have been made for £5.

    • Lol. Yes, that’s the BBC for you (I assume it’s the BBC as the images I saw online looked just like episodes of Doctor Who). The images do look iffy! But, hell, I LOVE the cheesy-looking BBC version of The Hitchhiker’s Guide To The Galaxy. If it’s shown on TV again, I’ll check this one out. : )

  6. Pingback: Heart-Shaped Box by Joe Hill (Book Review) | Cinema Parrot Disco

  7. Pingback: My Top Ten Books Read In 2016 | Cinema Parrot Disco

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s